There is a particular magic in lunchtime theatre and Someone’s Knockin’ at the Door, part of the Play, A Pie and A Pint series, captures it with gentle precision. In the intimate Traverse Theatre space, the boundary between audience and performer almost disappears, allowing every glance, pause, and knock at the door to carry extra weight.
Written by Milly Sweeney and inspired by a true story, the play follows Jack and Kathy, a working class couple whose memories and adventures are recalled with humour, tenderness, and occasional wistfulness. Jonathan Watson and Maureen Carr, two of Scotland’s most accomplished and beloved performers across stage and television, bring them vividly to life. As Jack and Kathy, they embody the archetypal Scottish pair, full of the contradictions of Scottish life: Catholic versus Protestant, art versus commerce, and rural versus urban.
Watson’s Jack is occasionally a dreamer, swept along by nostalgia and music; Carr’s Kathy is firmly grounded, a pragmatic counterbalance. Jack initially struggles to persuade his pregnant wife (unbeknown to him) to embark on the road trip at the story’s centre, but wins her over with the promise of a fish supper, a small, deliciously domestic incentive that reveals the intimacy and humour of their relationship. Their bickering is often comic; beneath it hums genuine affection, even as the story ultimately reveals that the couple divorced. In performance, however, the warmth and chemistry between Watson and Carr make Jack and Kathy feel fully alive, capturing the joy, tension, and shared history of a real relationship.
Jack’s love of The Beatles is a central aspect of his character. Like many men of his generation, it is a language through which he expresses love and emotion, it also helps him develop a more positive outlook on life. His recounting of the 1976 journey in search of Paul McCartney’s hideaway in Campbeltown, part pilgrimage, part adventure, becomes a meditation on youth, obsession and the enduring power of music as well as teenage dreams.
The narrative unfolds through the eyes of a grandchild working on a school project, a device that allows memory to flow naturally. Within this storytelling are cherished moments, deep sadness, bursts of laughter, and great joy. It is here, in the interplay of past and present, that the play finds its emotional centre. The minimal set and close proximity of the audience to the action amplify the intimacy, making you feel as though you are sitting at the scullery with Jack and Kathy, listening to their memories as if they were your own. By the final knock, laughter, nostalgia and a touch of wistfulness linger together. Someone’s Knockin’ at the Door is relatable and elegant in its simplicity, gentle in its observation and subtly thrilling in the way it reminds us of the stories, contradictions, and music that shape our lives.
Four Stars.
Reviewed by Richard Purden.
Theatre, Art and Film Reviews 
Leave a comment